Nomination Clarifications #4

[rfemod]

Thank you to everyone who has caught duplicates and other errors within the tagset! It seems we are on track to open sign-ups on time. However, there are a few leftover inquiries/notes.

Candela Obscura: Vassal & Veil
Is this separate from the canon fandom tag "Candela Obscura (Critical Role Web Series)" or can it be accepted under that?

Doctor Who & Related Fandoms
Bill Potts/Maria Jackson
Missy/Sarah Jane Smith
Rani Chandra/Maria Jackson
Sarah Jane Smith/Rose Tyler

Doctor Who is going to be split up into the various subdivisions. Which version would the nominators like for each ship?

Over the Limit:

Marvel Cinematic Universe
Carol Danvers/Monica Rambeau (MCU) - 530 works
Maria Hill/Natasha Romanov - 979 works

The Witcher (TV)
Tissaia de Vries/Yennefer z Vengerbergu | Yennefer of Vengerberg - 325 works

From Past Posts:

Dimension 20: The Seven
There is a canonical tag for "Dimension 20" and two synned tags referring to "The Seven". Would the nominator prefer to keep it separate?

Star Wars Legends - All Media Types
Winter Celchu/Leia Organa

Is there a more specific version than the "all media types" fandom that can be used?

Persona Series
The Persona Series have already been split up so if you nominated under this category, please go back and specify which one you want.

Nominators have 24 hours to respond, either here (anonymous commenting is on, screening isn't) or via email at rarefemslashexchangemod@gmail.com.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Here are all the fics for Carol Danvers/Monica Rambeau on AO3: https://archiveofourown.org/tags/Carol%20Danvers*s*Monica%20Rambeau/works

It looks like the over-the-limit results were for Carol Danvers/Maria Rambeau (which I didn't nominate).

[rfemod]

I'm so sorry about that. Clearly, I read it wrong and checked on the wrong ship. Thank you so much for catching that! It's now been added to the tagset. Again, apologies for the mix up! :)

[(Anonymous)]

No worries! Thanks for adding it to the tagset now.

[rfemod]

No problem! Thanks so much for understanding! :D

[fiachairecht]

I'm the Candela Obscura nominator - Vassal & Veil is the first of three-and-counting standalone chapters all using the same TTRPG system and taking place in the same universe, but there's no character crossover & they all take place at slightly different times. If things like Star Trek & Star Wars are being split up it makes sense that Candela should be too, ime!

(I won't be, like, heartbroken if you go with the canonical, it just seemed like you were leaning towards the 'specific installment of canon' side of things.)

[rfemod]

Thank you for the information! I am not familiar with the canon so I wasn't aware and I appreciate the explanation. They will be accepted as is then! :D

duplicate

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate in The Magnus Archives:

Basira Hussain/Alice "Daisy" Tonner (The Magnus Archives)
Basira Hussain/Daisy Tonner (TMA)

Re: duplicate

[rfemod]

Thank you for catching that! The duplicate has been deleted. :)

[shadaras]

Not the nominator, so absolutely defer to the nominator if they show up:

Winter Celchu/Leia Organa is generally from the Star Wars Legends Novels. I don't know which novel(s) in particular the nominator was thinking of, but would limiting it to the novels be enough, since that'd at least remove the AMT tag?

[rfemod]

Thank you for the information! I haven't heard from them yet, but I will add it under what you suggested if I don't. :D

[quailfence]

Not the nominatior

Rani Chandra/Maria Jackson - both are from the spinoff Sarah Jane Adevntures, and should probably appear under there

Bill Potts/Maria Jackson - Bill is from the 2005 revival, Maria is from SJA. Should probably go in crossovers

Missy/Sarah Jane Smith, Sarah Jane Smith/Rose Tyler - Sarah Jane has appeared in both the 1963 show and the 2005 revival, along with SJA; Missy and Rose have only appeared in the 2005 revival. Could go in either 2005 or crossovers depending on what era the nominations wants Sarah Jane to be from

[rfemod]

Thank you for the information! I will add the first two where you suggested and then wait to see about the others. If I don't hear back, I will add the other ones to the 2005 revival. :)

[quailfence]

Different thing:

“ Pocket Monsters: Sword & Shield | Pokemon Sword & Shield Versions “ is part of the main series and should be merged with it

[rfemod]

Thank you for catching that! It was my fault to insist on everything being separated and then accepting the overall tag. I'll make a note to make sure that they can all stay together for next year. :)